September 24, 2026
"Does not currently have a lease signed for the space." That's what a spokesperson for Jamestown, the company that owns Avenue East Cobb, told East Cobb this year when asked about the rumor that La Parrilla Mexican Restaurant was about to fill the old Tin Lizzy's spot. That statement leaves the La Parrilla rumor unconfirmed, and East Cobb has seen restaurant rumors circulate before.
One earlier rumor involved a much bigger name, a much longer rumor, and a much stranger ending.
In October 2025, word spread that Shake Shack had secured space at Merchants Walk, the Whole Foods and Kohl's shopping center on Johnson Ferry Road. Not a new building. An existing outparcel at 1281 Johnson Ferry, where Mirko Pasta had been serving build-your-own pasta bowls since 2011, right next to a shuttered Duck Donuts location. The plan, as reported, was for Shake Shack to combine both spaces into a single 3,600 square foot restaurant across from the Chipotle.
The comment sections lit up for months. People argued about whether Mirko deserved to survive, whether Shake Shack burgers were worth the hype, whether the neighborhood needed another burger option at all. Mirko's own management posted publicly that the restaurant wasn't closing and planned to stay open through June 2026.
Then, in mid-May 2026, Mirko Pasta quietly closed. No farewell tour, no countdown. Just gone.
And the Shake Shack never showed up. By July 2026, the real answer surfaced: the space is becoming a Nothing Bundt Cakes, the bundt cake franchise, in a location that had already cycled through Gigi's Cupcakes and then Duck Donuts before landing on the bundt cakes. The Shake Shack deal, once treated as settled fact, simply fell apart somewhere between the rumor and the lease.
Here's what that one outparcel has actually seen change hands over roughly five years:
| Tenant | Status |
|---|---|
| Gigi's Cupcakes | Closed years ago |
| Duck Donuts | Open six years, closed August 2025 |
| Shake Shack (rumored) | Reported October 2025, deal fell through |
| Nothing Bundt Cakes | Confirmed July 2026, opening in the former Duck Donuts space |
Meanwhile Mirko, in the space next door, went from "not closing" to closed in about a month.
Here's the part that didn't get the comment-section treatment. While the neighborhood argued about a burger chain that never arrived, several East Cobb restaurants closed over roughly the same six-month stretch, including two that had been part of the community for decades.
That's four closure stories across four different shopping centers in roughly the same six-month stretch, and none generated the kind of sustained chatter that a rumored Shake Shack did.
Which brings us back to that Jamestown quote at the top of this piece. The Tin Lizzy's space at Avenue East Cobb has sat empty since New Year's Eve, and the rumor filling that vacuum right now is La Parrilla. Jamestown's official answer, as of the most recent local reporting, is that nothing is signed.
Jamestown told East Cobb: "Does not currently have a lease signed for the space."
That's not a denial. It's also not a confirmation. It's exactly the kind of carefully worded statement that tends to get lost in translation by the time it reaches a Facebook group, which is worth remembering the next time a specific restaurant name starts circulating for a specific empty storefront.
While the rumor about La Parrilla plays out, here's what's real and dated in East Cobb as of this writing:
Two of those are already serving customers. Two are still just plans on paper, which is exactly the distinction that matters.
The pattern here isn't complicated once you see it laid out. A big, recognizable name attached to a specific address spreads fast, because it's the kind of thing people want to repeat to their neighbors. A quiet closure of a restaurant that's been part of the neighborhood for twenty or thirty years doesn't spread the same way, because there's no exciting news to share, just an ending.
The gap between those two speeds is where a lot of East Cobb's dinner planning goes wrong. Someone tells you Shake Shack is coming to Merchants Walk, and eight months later you're standing in front of a bundt cake shop wondering what happened. Someone tells you La Parrilla signed a lease at Avenue, and the honest answer, at least for now, is that they haven't.
If you want to know what's actually true about a specific address, the property's own leasing announcements and the restaurant's own social media accounts are more reliable than a comment thread, no matter how many people are repeating the same story. A grand opening date and a working phone number mean something happened. Everything else is still just a rumor with good timing.
East Cobb's shopping centers are going to keep turning over tenants the way they always have. Some of what replaces them will be worth the wait, the way Tenku's rooftop bar has been for people who wanted a reason to linger longer than a quick sushi run. Some of it may be more modest than the rumors suggested. Either way, the neighborhood keeps changing in small, specific ways that are easy to miss if you're only paying attention to the loudest story.
If you're the kind of East Cobb resident who tracks this stuff because you care about the place, you're exactly who this was written for. And if a friend or neighbor ever mentions they're thinking about buying or selling nearby, Kimberly Eslinger is always glad to be the person they get pointed toward.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Her empathetic nature enables her to get to the core of her clients’ needs and wants and her infectious personality helps make the process fun! She experiences extreme joy as she journeys alongside her clients seeking to find their next place to call "home".